The Real Story and Meaning behind “Send in the Clowns”, the Signature Song of Judy Collins

Stephen Sondheim’s “Send in the Clowns” is a masterpiece of modern musical theater, a haunting ballad that distills the pain of missed chances and quiet regret. Written in 1973 for “A Little Night Music”, it was born from a specific dramatic need but has since become a timeless meditation on love’s missteps. Its backstory ties to Sondheim’s work with director Harold Prince, and its meaning unfolds through Desirée Armfeldt, the character it was crafted for.

Inspired by Ingmar Bergman’s “Smiles of a Summer Night”, “A Little Night Music” is a witty exploration of romance in early 20th-century Sweden. Desirée, played by Glynis Johns in the original Broadway run, is an aging actress navigating her career and a rekindled spark with Fredrik Egerman, her former lover now married to a younger woman. “Send in the Clowns” arrives as their reunion falters—a moment of raw reflection on their misaligned desires. The title nods to a circus trope: clowns rush in to distract when a performance fails. For Desirée, it’s a wry plea for absurdity to mask her heartbreak. It happens in the circus, and it happens at a rodeo, to distract the bull from the rider. Clowns are the distraction.

Sondheim wrote the song quickly, in two days, tailoring it to Johns’ breathy, limited range with short, aching phrases. It’s a perfect fit for Desirée’s vulnerability, and its lyrics peel back layers of irony and sorrow. Let’s dive into some key lines:

• “Isn’t it rich? Are we a pair? Me here at last on the ground, you in mid-air”: The opening drips with sarcasm. Desirée feels earthbound, worn by life, while Fredrik floats above—out of reach, emotionally or otherwise.
• “One of us tearing around, one that can’t move”: This line (sometimes less quoted but resonant in certain interpretations) captures their dynamic starkly. Desirée is the one “tearing around,” restless in her pursuit of meaning, while Fredrik, bound by his marriage or indecision, “can’t move.” It’s a snapshot of their disconnect—one frenetic, the other static.
• “Just when I’d stopped opening doors, finally knowing the one that I wanted was yours”: Here’s the gut punch. After years of guarding her heart, Desirée realizes Fredrik was her true desire—too late, as that door’s now shut.
• “Isn’t it rich? Isn’t it queer? Losing my timing this late in my career”: The repetition of “rich” sharpens the irony, and “queer” (meaning “odd” in its vintage sense) highlights the strangeness of her plight. “Career” doubles as her acting life and her romantic arc, both stumbling now.

The song wasn’t about a real person but was a dramatic creation for Desirée. Sondheim drew from Johns’ fragile intensity and Prince’s vision for a showstopper. Its power lies in its specificity yet its universality—anyone who’s loved and lost can hear their story in it.

Judy Collins and “Send in the Clowns”

For music blog readers, Judy Collins’ 1975 recording of “Send in the Clowns” is likely the version etched in memory. Featured on her album Judith, it hit No. 36 on the Billboard Hot 100, later climbing to No. 19 in 1977. With her luminous voice and delicate phrasing, Collins turned Sondheim’s stage piece into a pop-folk classic, earning a Grammy nod and making it her signature song.

Collins discovered the song through Sondheim, who played it for her pre-premiere. Enchanted, she recorded it with lush strings, softening its theatrical bite into something more intimate. Her take emphasizes the song’s emotional core—less Desirée’s story, more a personal lament. She’s sung it countless times since, each performance a touchstone for fans who tie her voice to its melancholy.

Does it reflect her romance with Stephen Stills? No. Their stormy late-’60s relationship—immortalized in Stills’ “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes”—fuels speculation, but “Send in the Clowns” isn’t about them. Sondheim wrote it for Desirée, not Collins, and it predates any post-breakup narrative. That’s the technical explanation.

Collins has never framed it as autobiographical, yet, just before she performs it, there’s a storytelling session about her relationship with Stephen Stills. The confusion likely arises from her soulful delivery, which invites listeners to weave their own tales into it— her tale of Stephen Stills included. However, specifically, its roots are theatrical, not personal — yet Collins has said that the lyric “One of us tearing around, one that can’t move” can refer to the overwhelming sadness felt by the “one that can’t move.”

Collins’ claim to “Send in the Clowns” showcases her interpretive alchemy. She didn’t write it, and it wasn’t for her, but she made it hers. For fans, her version is a bridge from Broadway to the heart—a reminder that a great song can belong to whoever sings it best. When Judy sends in the clowns, they feel like they’re stepping into your life.

Related Posts

• 

  Grace Potter at Extra Innings.
  Grace Potter at Extra Innings.
• 

  Beck: The Cosmic Closer
  Beck: The Cosmic Closer
• 

  Gary Clark Jr.: The Bluesman’s Roar
  Gary Clark Jr.: The Bluesman’s Roar
• 

  Boyz II Men: The Soulful Serenade
  Boyz II Men: The Soulful Serenade